Updated November 2026

If you are flying Southwest with a pet in the cabin, the carrier you choose matters as much as the pet inside it. Southwest pet carrier restrictions center on size, the carrier’s ability to stay closed and secure under the seat, and whether the pet can stand and turn around comfortably. For most cabin travelers with cats or small dogs, a soft-sided carrier is the easier choice because it flexes to fit the space. A hard-sided carrier suits travelers who want a firm, predictable shell and have confirmed the dimensions match the airline’s limits.

Criteria Soft-sided carrier Hard-sided carrier
Fit under the seat Flexes to fit tight spaces Must match dimensions exactly
Weight when empty Light, easy to carry for long walks through the airport Heavier, more bulk to handle
Ventilation Mesh panels on several sides Vents usually limited to the top and sides
Structure and protection Softer, less protection in a bump Rigid walls protect against pressure
Cleaning Machine washable on many models Wipe down the interior and shell

Size Compliance Under Southwest Rules

Southwest’s pet carrier size limits are set around what fits under a seat in front of you, and the carrier must stay within those dimensions with the pet inside. Soft-sided carriers have the advantage here because their walls compress slightly when pushed into a tight space. Hard-sided carriers look neat but leave no room for error, so measure the outside dimensions, including handles and wheels, before you buy. Winner: soft-sided carrier, since it gives you more room to meet the limit without sacrificing the pet’s space.

Comfort and Pet Space

Your pet needs to stand up, turn around and lie down during the flight. Soft carriers with a padded base and a flexible shape can make a small footprint feel more usable, especially for cats. Hard carriers offer a consistent interior but may feel tight if the internal height is low. Winner: soft-sided carrier for most cats and small dogs, provided the padding stays flat and the pet cannot poke through the mesh. We also found Air France Pet Carrier Dimensions (2026): Soft vs Hard Carriers Compared useful on this point.

Security and Ventilation

A carrier must close securely and provide steady airflow. Soft-sided carriers usually have mesh on several sides, which helps air circulate, but zippers need to lock or be fastened so a pet cannot push through. Hard-sided carriers use latches and fixed vents, which many owners find easier to check at a glance. Winner: hard-sided carrier for owners who want a visible, mechanical lock and simple vent inspection.

Durability and Handling

Expect the carrier to be lifted, dropped and squeezed in overhead bins or on the jet bridge. Hard shells resist crushing and keep their shape, which owners often report as a plus on busy connections. Soft carriers are lighter and easier to sling over a shoulder, which matters on long walks through terminals. Winner: depends on the traveler, though a rigid shell edges ahead for rough handling.

Pros & Cons

Soft-sided carrier

  • Pro: flexes to fit under the seat more easily.
  • Pro: lighter to carry through the airport.
  • Con: less protection if bumped or compressed.

Hard-sided carrier

  • Pro: firm shell protects the pet and holds its shape.
  • Pro: latches and vents are easy to check.
  • Con: must match the size limit exactly, leaving little margin.

Which Should You Choose?

  • Choose a soft-sided carrier if you are flying with a cat or small dog, need the most room to meet the under-seat limit, and value a lighter bag. Try the View on Amazon as a common soft-sided option.
  • Choose a hard-sided carrier if your pet is calm in enclosed spaces, you want a rigid shell, and you have verified the exact dimensions. The View on Amazon is a frequently recommended hard-sided model.

For more background on how airline limits apply to specific carriers, see Southwest Airlines Pet Carrier Rules: What Fits Under the Seat and Southwest Airline Pet Carrier Requirements (2026): Soft vs Hard Carrier Compared. If you are still weighing your options, Soft vs Hard Pet Carriers (and Backpacks vs Totes) covers the trade-offs in more depth.

FAQ

Do Southwest pet carrier restrictions apply to all pets?

Southwest allows cabin pets that meet its carrier and age rules, but specific eligibility should be confirmed with the airline before travel. Consult the airline directly for current requirements. For another angle, check out Air Canada Pet Carrier Dimensions (2026): Soft vs Hard Carrier Compared.

Can a soft carrier be used on a Southwest flight?

Yes, soft-sided carriers are accepted as long as they stay within the size limits and the pet remains fully inside and secured for the whole flight.

What happens if my carrier is too big?

An oversized carrier may not be allowed on board and could require you to check it or change flights. Measure the carrier with the pet inside and confirm limits before you arrive at the airport.

Conclusion

For most travelers with cats or small dogs, a soft-sided carrier offers the best balance of fit and weight under Southwest pet carrier restrictions. Hard-sided carriers reward owners who want a rigid shell and have measured carefully. Always check the current size and policy details with Southwest before you book.

Claire Whitaker

About Claire Whitaker

Claire Whitaker is part of our editorial team and reviews and edits our everyday pet gear guides, checking product details against manufacturer specifications and owner feedback.